RES auction for PVs with batteries in March

An inaugural RES auction offering 200 MW for photovoltaics with batteries, scheduled to take place March, will require successful bidders to accept greater grid-injection limits.

The starting price for this auction, still unknown, will be set at a higher level than usual as the cost of incorporating batteries to photovoltaics will be factored in.

It will serve as a pilot procedure that will help shape new auctions to be established by the energy ministry for RES installations.

Current RES auction terms and conditions are expected to soon undergo major changes, which, as a result, will include limiting participation to bidders committing to electrify their projects by specific dates.

The energy ministry plans to announced the March auction in February. Besides its starting price, to be set by a special committee established by the ministry to oversee matters concerning RES penetration, other auction details that remain pending include battery-type and battery-duration standards.

It is already considered certain that investors behind older projects possessing connection terms will need to commit to accepting higher grid-injection restrictions than the current 28 percent level, set in 2022. The aforementioned committee will also be setting these new rates, possibly at levels of between 40 and 50 percent.

Energy transition cost a ‘risk for EU industrial competitiveness’

The possibility of European industry facing persistently higher energy costs compared to the US and other global and regional players as the energy transition proceeds could become a bigger threat  than the energy crisis itself, according to a study on EU competitiveness conducted by Brussels-based think tank Bruegel.

The study, presented yesterday to the EU’s 27 finance ministers during a Eurogroup meeting, gives rise to a range of issues, from taxation and regulated tariffs to competition between big and small countries, while also making note of considerable energy quantities required to develop green technologies.

The first and main question raised by the study enquires whether the recovery of energy-transition costs should continue to be made through electricity tariffs or via general tax policies of EU member states.

A second question considers whether the tax distribution balance between households and industry should be altered. The study also explores the need for a tax redistribution between energy-intensive and non energy-intensive enterprises.

It also notes that, in the context of the single market, energy-consumption increases by large countries come at the expense of countries with smaller energy needs.

A fifth main point raised by the Bruegel study questions whether it makes sense to invest in renewable energy technologies such as solar panels, for example, when the production of polysilicon, a key component in the production of solar panels, requires extremely large amounts of energy.

According to the study, the anticipated prevalence of renewables will lead to a decrease in electricity prices but part of the decline will be offset by cost increases concerning a range of tariffs, fees and various policies.

IPTO pitches Green Aegean to new German ambassador

Greek power grid operator IPTO’s chief executive officer Manos Manousakis has held a meeting with Germany’s newly appointed ambassador to Greece, Andreas Kindl, to promote the operator’s proposal for a Green Aegean grid interconnection plan, envisaged to run from Greece to Germany’s south.

To date, German officials have remained reserved, as was highlighted by a meeting last November between Greek Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis and German Chancellor Olaf Scholz. The Greek leader made note of the Green Aegean project, describing it as a step towards independence from Russian energy, without reciprocation.

The Chancellor’s lack of expression on the project does not necessarily indicate that Germany is opposed to the Greek plan. It promises to be mutually beneficial for both countries. Germany encounters bigger energy needs during winter while Greece must deal with greater energy demand in the summer.

The meeting between Manousakis, IPTO’s CEO, with Germany’s new ambassador to Greece, could end up generating momentum for further talks between officials and convergence.

IPTO has expressed preference for a HVDC-technology subsea route for the Green Aegean grid interconnection that would pass through the Adriatic Sea to Slovenia, followed by an overland route to Austria and Germany’s south.

IPTO recently held related talks with TenneT, Germany’s biggest power grid operator, and Slovenian operator ELES.

 

RES project grid applications reach unrealistic level of 42 GW

RES project applications being submitted to power grid operator IPTO by investors, for grid capacity reservations, have continued at an alarming rate, resulting in an enormous and unrealistic wave of applications representing a total of roughly 42 GW, energypress sources have informed.

The applications concern more than 1,700 prospective RES units holding either producer certificates or production licenses and representing an overall capacity of 34.1 GW, as well as group applications representing 7.9 GW in prospective RES units, the sources noted.

In addition to these grid capacity-reservation applications totaling 42 GW, 15 GW in RES units currently under development have received finalized connection offers, while 10.6 GW in RES units are operating, according to IPTO’s updated ten-year development program covering 2024 to 2033.

This essentially means that RES projects representing an overall capacity of 67.6 GW have either secured grid reservations or submitted applications for reservations.

Quite clearly, a large number of the 42-GW in RES projects for which grid-reservation requests have been submitted will not be developed. The upgraded National Energy and Climate Plan for 2050 has set a 54.4-GW target for installed capacity covering photovoltaics, onshore wind farms, combined cooling, heat and power (CCHP) projects, biomass-biogas plants, and small-scale hydropower plants.

 

Talks with Libya for energy ties, grid link, despite Turkish pact

The prospect of a Greek-Libyan electrical interconnection appears to have been tabled for discussion between Greek officials and Libya’s provisional Government of National Unity, led by Abdul Hamid Dbeibeh, despite issues between the two sides over a Libyan-Turkish pact signed in 2019.

Greece’s Chargé d’Affaires in Libya, Agapios Kalognomis, held a meeting with Osama Al-Darrat, the Libyan Prime Minister’s adviser for electricity and renewable energy, around mid-December, the electrical interconnection being at the heart of the talks on strengthening cooperation between the two sides in the energy sector, energypress sources have informed, confirming Libyan media reports.

Greek power grid operator IPTO appears to have been informed on the development and raised it for consideration, within its competence.

It remains unclear if discussions so far have included a proposed route for the interconnection, in order to determine whether issues could arise regarding the Libyan-Turkish pact and, if so, how these may be addressed.

As for renewables, the prospect of collaboration with Libyan state-owned Renewable Energy Holding appears to have been discussed in greater detail, according to certain sources.

Electricity producers’ payment upper limit now lifted

Remuneration upper limits imposed on all electricity producers as one of a number of emergency measures implemented by authorities during the energy crisis have just been lifted, effective as of January 1, a move representing a significant step in the wholesale electricity market’s return to normality.

In the retail electricity market, subsidies offered to all consumers during the energy crisis were also lifted with the arrival of the new year.

The government introduced remuneration upper limits for electricity producers on July 7, 2022, at the height of the energy crisis, as a tool for recovering windfall profits, which were injected into the Energy Transition Fund to finance electricity subsidies offered by the state to all consumers.

A preceding remuneration system for electricity producers, introduced as part of the target model, has now been reinstated in place of the upper limits. A marginal price model, it sets payment levels for electricity producers based on the highest-price production unit brought into play every day.

Under the emergency measure imposing remuneration upper limits, all electricity producers, regardless of technology, were subjected to payment restrictions that took into account respective operating costs.

RES facilities faced a remuneration upper limit of 85 euros per MWh, while hydropower units were subjected to a payment limit of 112 euros per MWh. The remuneration upper-limit for natural gas-fueled power stations was revised monthly so that wildly fluctuating factors such as emission right costs and natural gas prices could be factored in.

The next and final step for the wholesale electricity market’s complete return to normality entails lifting an extraordinary levy imposed on natural gas used for electricity production. The energy ministry has noted it intends to proceed with this step early in 2024. However, a legislative revision by the ministry will be needed.

 

Measures freeing grid space headed for Parliament

The energy ministry, seeking to encourage further RES investment, plans to soon submit to Parliament a comprehensive package of measures designed to free electrical grid space and make available capacity for new RES units.

These interventions will enable power grid operator IPTO to increase the number of new connection terms granted to RES investors.

The ministry’s package of measures, which could be submitted to Parliament before January is out, are expected to include initiatives such as greater grid-injection restrictions as well as terms promoting battery installations at RES facilities without batteries.

The measures will be implemented at a latter stage, as part of a second wave of efforts, by a project management group established by the ministry. This group has been tasked with finding solutions for greater RES penetration and optimal management of the grid’s limited capacity.

The group will need to address and fine-tune details that determine the extent of grid-injection restrictions; specify which RES units will be subjected to these new restrictions; and also inform which RES units may install batteries and under what terms.

The group’s effort will be aligned with the National Energy and Climate Plan’s goals set for 2030.

 

 

Mytilineos secures €400m EIB loan for swifter RES growth

Mytilineos Energy & Metals has secured 400 million euros in European Investment Bank (EIB) funding for the purpose of accelerating renewable energy production across Greece and other EU member states.

The Mytilineos group has shaped a strategy to develop, by 2027, a portfolio of solar energy projects and battery energy storage systems (BESS) enabling additional production capacity of approximately 2.6 GW.

The investment’s overall cost is estimated at 2.5 billion euros. All projects will be developed within the EU.

The EIB financing, linked to the EIB’s support for new investments in convergence regions where per capita income is lower than the EU average, confirms the bank’s commitment to equitable growth and convergence of living standards in the EU.

EIB Managing Director and Head of Operations Jean-Christophe Laloux and Hristos Gavalas, Chief Treasury & IR Officer and Executive Board Member at Mytilineos, signed a ten-year loan agreement in Athens on December 21.

This new financing agreement stems from an EIB support package for RepowerEU, the EU’s ambitious and lucrative plan aiming to reduce dependence on fossil fuel imports, accelerate the green transition, and help Europe achieve zero-carbon emissions by 2050.

PPC to present ambitious business plan at London event

Power utility PPC is currently adding final touches to a new and highly ambitious four-year business plan scheduled to be announced January 23 in London, at a Capital Markets Day event, before an audience of international analysts and institutional investors.

They will be expecting news from PPC’s leadership on the energy group’s priorities abroad, including its next big steps planned for the Balkans; a retail energy expansion plan through the group’s fully-owned Kotsovolos electrical and electronics retail chain, a leading force in the Greek market; as well as news on the company’s plans for promising new sectors such as fiber optics and waste management through public-private partnerships.

PPC is also looking to capitalize on company-owned properties that have remained unutilized for decades.

Over the past few years, PPC has enjoyed a period of tremendous growth that has led to a 50 percent increase in financial figures, over 9 million customers, 14 GW in renewable energy projects, and 340,000 kilometers of networks.

Under the leadership of its CEO Giorgos Stassis, PPC is steadily growing into an energy group of international proportions and a dominant force in southeast Europe. Investments in Romania are a key part of this strategy.

 

IPTO’s role in accelerating green transition, transforming Greece into green energy exporter

By Manos Manousakis*

2023, which is drawing to a close, has affirmed a familiar truth: the impact of climate change requires the formulation, adoption, and implementation of policies addressing recurrent extreme phenomena, including temperature rise, desertification, water scarcity, and environmental pollution. We owe it to the future generations το slow down and ultimately reverse climate deregulation, making the green energy transition, contingent on the strengthening and expansion of electricity grids, an absolute priority.

To grasp the enormity of the challenges posed by the climate crisis and its ensuing phenomena, consider that in the summer of 2023, the Electricity Transmission System grappled with successive or simultaneous fires in Attica (Kouvaras, Dervenochoria), Corinthia (Loutraki), and Thrace.

During these natural disasters, a total of 1,400 switch operations were documented, with flames literally reaching beneath the Transmission Lines. Despite this, the system remained resilient, and the supply of electricity to the distribution network was uninterrupted.

Due to the climate crisis, we also faced unprecedented floods in Thessaly triggered by storms Daniel and Elias. These events led to the collapse of two pylons (400 and 150 kV). Again, the system demonstrated resilience and IPTO promptly restored the damages. However, we recognize that sustaining the reliable operation of the networks necessitates more investments and actions. This commitment is reflected not only in the EUR 200 million Asset Modernisation Programme which we are currently implementing and is due to be completed by 2026, but also in the flood protection measures for our substations and the integration of innovative technologies for the monitoring and maintenance of critical equipment.

However, the energy transition demands not only bolstering the resilience of networks but also expanding them. This reality has been acknowledged by the incoming Belgian EU Presidency, which has listed the increase of investments in the grids among its main priorities. This follows the Action Plan recently unveiled by the European Commission, which recognizes that grids are the “missing link” of the transition. The Plan delineates specific actions and incentives to secure the estimated €600 billion investment required by the end of the decade to achieve the EU’s climate targets.

To meet the ambitious European and international targets, it is imperative to invest in both national networks and cross-border and trans-continental electricity interconnections. These investments will facilitate the optimal utilization of green energy across diverse geographical areas and climate zones.

The role of IPTO

In this regard, IPTO has a pivotal role to play, as it spearheads projects contributing not only to the increased integration of Renewable Energy Sources (RES) in the country’s energy mix, now nearing 50%, but also advancing a key objective of the national energy strategy: transforming Greece into a green energy exporter to Central Europe. This will be achieved through the implementation of cross -border interconnections designed to export surplus electricity generated within the country. Notably, this initiative aligns with the plan to develop 2 GW of Offshore Wind Farms by the end of the decade, capitalizing on the substantial and continuous interest in renewable energy investment that surpasses domestic demand.

At the heart of this plan is the Greece-Cyprus-Israel interconnection, with IPTO having recently assumed the role of the project promoter through its special purpose vehicle, the Great Sea Interconnector.

Notably, during COP28, IPTO signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) with the Ministry of Energy, Trade, and Industry of Cyprus and the Abu Dhabi -based fund TAQA for their potential participation in the project. We have also signed a preliminary agreement with Israeli fund Aluma. Furthermore, funds from the USA and other countries have expressed interest in the project.

These developments are tangible proof for the investor interest after IPTO assumed the role of project promoter of the Great Sea Interconnector. Given its proven expertise and robust financial profile, IPTO is well positioned to execute this highly demanding project efficiently. Construction is slated to commence in 2024.

Given our emphasis on export interconnections, we are maturing a second High Voltage Direct Current (HVDC) interconnection with Italy with a capacity of 1000 MW, which triple the electricity transmission capacity between the two countries. Additionally, the recently completed second interconnection with Bulgaria and the planned second interconnection with Albania align with this overarching strategy.

Simultaneously, we are exploring the feasibility of establishing a direct electricity corridor with Central Europe. South Germany stands out as the ideal endpoint for this corridor, due to its robust electricity system and significant demand for green energy.

The Green Aegean Interconnector, as the Greece-South Germany corridor is called, has significant synergies with the Greece-Egypt interconnection (project GREGY, implemented by Elica of the Copelouzos Group), in which we are actively engaged. Furthermore, it aligns with a visionary project, whose planning we have recently initiated: the electrical interconnection with Saudi Arabia, referred to as the Saudi Greek Interconnection. To facilitate this endeavor, we are in the process of establishing a special purpose company jointly with the Saudi Transmission System Operator, National Grid, who expressed its keen interest in the project during the recent Arab-Hellenic Chamber’s Economic Forum held in Athens.

These projects play a crucial role in promoting not only Europe’s energy transition but also its energy independence from Russia and the exploration of new energy suppliers—a key objective of REPower EU.

As we enter 2024, it becomes imperative to expedite the transition to the clean energy era. It is essential to underscore that the journey of the green transition may pose challenges, yet it is a one-way street, a path that cannot and should not be reversed.

*Mr. Manos Manousakis is the Chairman and CEO of Independent Power Transmission Operator (IPTO).

 

Wholesale power price drop recorded on Christmas Day

The combination of increased electricity imports, high RES production and reduced energy demand resulted in a reduction of wholesale electricity prices on Christmas Day, including a near-zero-level market clearing price.

On Christmas Day, the market-clearing price dropped to as low as 0.04 cents per MWh, while the day’s average price was 98.09 euros per MWh.

Electricity imports comprised 34.72 percent of the country’s energy mix on Christmas Day, followed by renewables (32.14%), natural gas-fueled production (21.66%), hydropower (8.27%), and lignite-fired generation (0.27%).

Market conditions were similar on Boxing Day, the average market-clearing price dropping 10.94 percent to 87.37 euros per MWh. The day’s market-clearing price low was 2 euros per MWh, while the maximum price reached 135.28 euros per MWh.

As was the case on Christmas Day, electricity imports also dominated the energy mix on Boxing Day with a 33.91 percent share, followed by renewables (32.66%), natural gas-fueled production (21.98%), hydropower (8.02%), and lignite-fired generation (0.26%).

As for today, the average market-clearing price is forecast to rise mildly, by 3.8 percent, to 90.69 euros per MWh, as a result of greater energy-mix contributions by natural gas and lignite and a drop in RES input, while the day’s lows and highs are expected to reach 35 euros per MWh and 137.39 euros per MWh, respectively.

Once again, electricity imports are planned to dominate the energy mix today with a 31.45 percent share, followed by natural gas-fueled production (28.55%), renewables (24.99%) hydropower (7.74%), and lignite-fired generation (3.97%).

It is also worth pointing out that, over the past seven-day period, the market-clearing price has remained below the 100 euro per MWh barrier for five days, exceeding this level on just two days.

 

Energy exchange’s preliminary PPA plan approved by officials

A preliminary plan prepared by the energy exchange for a platform hosting renewable-energy power purchase agreements (PPAs) has been given the green light for further development by both the energy ministry and RAAEY, the Regulatory Authority for Waste, Energy and Water, energypress sources have informed.

The energy exchange’s plan is divided into two stages corresponding to the maturity levels of the PPA market.

During preceding public consultation, RAAEY had presented three alternative models for development. The energy exchange opted to work on a model whose first stage – at least – would primarily enable participants to express interest.

At its meetings with the energy ministry and RAAEY, the energy exchange presented a proposal detailing a standardized form for PPA contracts, as well as draft rules on how the platform should operate.

In addition, at these meetings, the energy exchange stressed that, despite its limited initial needs, the PPA platform plan would need to take into account, from the outset, the prospect of operating in mature and developed market conditions.

Industry troubled by PPA terms, seen as ‘out of touch’

Greek industrial players are expressing strong reservations about the prospects of green power purchase agreements (PPAs), which have been delayed by well over a year, their terms now considered out of touch.

Industry’s concerns have arisen as the energy ministry seeks to find a solution that would unblock the development of 2.5 GW in solar energy projects under contract for their supply to industrial consumers.

When talks had first begun on the introduction of PPAs, the now-delayed associated RES projects were expected to be operational in 2025. But it now appears they will not be ready to operate until 2027.

Ten-year PPAs already signed offer fixed energy prices to industrial players, who agreed on these deals anticipating the considerable energy-cost benefits of the first few years would eventually fade out towards the end of their ten-year period.

Industry deems latest PPA price levels on offer as excessive, greatly increasing the entrepreneurial risk involved.

EVIKEN, the Association of Industrial Energy Consumers, in a letter forwarded to energy minister Thodoris Skylakakis, has called for measures that would help industrial producers establish PPAs. The association has recommended cutting the duration of new PPAs to two years from ten years at present.

Tumbling battery costs boost gov’t energy storage plans

A steep drop in the price of lithium, the key component for batteries, down 30 percent compared to last month and 80 percent year-on-year, promises to boost the government’s ability to free up more grid capacity through greater installation of energy-storage units.

The plunge in the cost of battery production, a sector dominated by China with a global market share of over 50 percent, will certainly enhance a new RES plan being prepared by the Greek energy ministry. Its details are expected to be announced within the first two months of 2024.

Energy minister Thodoris Skylakakis will be able to plan more ambitiously for the development of roof-mounted solar panels, solar farms and incorporation of batteries behind the meter to such projects.

The new RES plan will include, as a key feature, a section promoting the availability of low-cost renewable energy to industry through bilateral contracts.

Lithium prices have fallen to 97,000 yuan per ton, down from 300,000 yuan in July and 500,000 yuan in January. The price of a lithium battery has dropped to an all-time low, close to 139 US dollars per kWh, according to a BloombergNEF (BNEF) survey published in November.

Several months ago, the Greek energy ministry, driven by the continual drop in battery prices, halved its energy-storage investment support offered through auction by RAAEY, the Regulatory Authority for Energy, Environment, and Water, to 100,000 euros per MW at a second auction. Support of 200,000 euros per MW had been offered at a first auction.

This reduced requirement for state investment support will enable the ministry to stage energy-storage auctions on a more regular basis, enhancing RES penetration around the country.

 

Local solar energy project on EU Innovation Fund support list

An innovative solar energy project being developed in Greece by German-based Protarget is among seventeen small-scale pilot projects selected for funding support through the European Commission’s Innovation Fund.

The project, named Sunbrewed, concerns the development of a customized solar thermal system in combination with a steam accumulator at a brewery, the initiative’s aim being to fully cover the facility’s fluctuating energy needs for production and preserve the availability, at all times, of thermal energy through storage technology.

In addition, as stated in the project’s analysis, renewable and decarbonized heat generated by the system promises to enable a reduction in heavy fuel oil consumption and CO2 emissions.

The project is one of seven selected for the Innovation Fund’s renewable energy category. These seven projects will receive an overall sum of 24.4 million euros from the Innovation Fund, supporting a total of 17 projects with provisions totaling 65 million euros.

Each of the 17 projects is expected to receive funding ranging from 1.6 million to 4.5 million euros, funds stemming from the EU Emission Trading System. Exact amounts to be awarded to each project will be established once the selection procedure has been finalized.

The selected projects cover a wide range of sectors with a particular focus on the manufacture of materials and equipment related to renewable energy, glass, ceramics and building materials. The list also includes projects in the domains of energy storage, iron, steel, refineries, chemicals, cement, lime and hydrogen.

This financial support, the European Commission has noted, will help companies in Europe, including small-scale enterprises, bring innovative technologies to market for energy-intensive industries, renewable energy and energy storage.

Protarget is active globally in the field of innovation with a range of applications concerning industrial-scale solar thermal technology.

R Energy1 Holdings’ founder, majority shareholder buys back LAMDA Developments’ 20% stake

R Energy1 Holdings’ founder and majority shareholder George M. Rokas buys back LAMDA Developments’ 20% stake in the company, supporting its significant value upside and further growth potential

Athens, December 19, 2023 – R Energy1 Holding S.A. today announced that G. Rokas Holdings S.M.S.A.—a company 100% owned by George M. Rokas, has concluded the Share Purchase Agreement with LAMDA ENERGY INVESTMENTS S.M.S.A.– a 100% subsidiary of LAMDA DEVELOPMENT S.A, (“LAMDA”), regarding the acquisition of:

  • 20% of the Company’s share capital, as well as
  • an Euro 10-million convertible bond loan, for a total cash consideration of Euro 21.6 million.

G. Rokas Holdings S.M.S.A has initiated the process of converting the above-mentioned Euro 10.0 million convertible bond loan into shares, thus raising— upon conversion process completion, its total interest in R Energy1 Holding S.A. to over 70%.

“Buying back LAMDA’s stake is yet another powerful ‘vote of confidence’ signal in R Energy1 Holdings’ business plan implementation focus and further growth potential.” stated Mr. George M. Rokas, R Energy1 Holdings’ Chairman and CEO.  “We are moving ahead, building on solid foundations, dedicated to place R Energy1 Holding in a leading position in the Greek RES industry and ensure continuous profitable and sustainable growth. The entrance of LAMDA into the share capital of R Energy1 Holding has been a milestone towards this journey. We thank them for the trust they have placed in our company.”

 

 

 

 

 

European Commission offers mixed report on revised NECP

A European Commission appraisal of Greece’s revised National Energy and Climate Plan has confirmed the growing momentum of the country’s RES market, while highlighting a number of weaknesses that will need to be addressed before the plan is finalized.

The Brussels report recognizes the country’s potential to exceed EU targets and achieve a 44 percent share of renewables in total gross national energy consumption, compared to the corresponding European target of 39 percent.

The inclusion of targets for heating and cooling, as well as for the transport sector, were also deemed favorably.

As for the Greek NECP’s negatives concerning renewables, the European Commission made note of the absence of specific RES targets or a road map for all industrial sectors.

The Brussels report also noted a specific plan was also missing for the domain of Renewable Fuels of Non-Biological Origin (RFNBOs).

In addition, the European Commission acknowledges that the revised NECP includes a comprehensive list of measures, either adopted or to be adopted, to enhance the development of renewables, but underlines the absence of a clear timetable as well as the lack of a clear distinction between existing measures and new measures.

Brussels also made note of shortcomings in the plan’s decarbonization procedure, noting, on the one hand, lack of progress on international commitments included in the Paris Agreement and, on the other, the absence of specific timetable and dates concerning the withdrawal of lignite from the country’s energy mix.

 

Helleniq Energy: Clarity needed on DEPA Commercial future

The future of gas company DEPA Commercial, whose privatization of the state’s 65 percent stake was postponed about a month ago, needs to be clarified in the immediate future, within the next three to six months, Andreas Siamisiis, chief executive of the Helleniq Energy group, holding a 35 percent stake in the gas company, has noted.

DEPA Commercial is currently developing business interests that directly compete against those of Helleniq Energy. These interests include participation in new gas-fueled power stations, both in Greece and abroad.

Subsequently, the current status, under which Helleniq Energy holds a 35 percent in DEPA Commercial, cannot be maintained. Helleniq Energy will need to sell its stake in the gas company, possibly to the Greek State or a third party.

Greek privatization fund TAIPED postponed its sale of DEPA Commercial until the company’s business plan, which includes an expansion strategy, begins reaping rewards, effectively meaning that no further steps concerning the company’s sale should be expected before late 2024 or early 2025.

As for Helleniq Energy, the company intends, in 2024, to intensify its efforts in the Bulgarian RES market, especially photovoltaics.

Helleniq Energy currently holds a 360-MW portfolio of RES projects in operation, along with projects at advanced stages of development, which, once launched, promise to boost the group’s total RES capacity to 1 GW over the next 18 months.

Besides its interests in renewables, Helleniq Energy is monitoring the sale process of Russian multinational energy corporation Lukoil’s refinery in Bulgaria. It is the only refinery in the neighboring country.

Although a Helleniq Energy move to acquire this refinery is hard to imagine, as it would run contrary to the group’s transformation plan, it cannot be ruled out as any new buyer might be interested in exporting fuel to Greece. Helleniq Energy may choose to buy the Lukoil refinery to block further competition in the Greek market.

Whatever the outcome, Helleniq Energy would not be prepared to spend big on such an acquisition.

 

 

New energy self-consumption framework within 1Q of ‘24

The country’s updated regulatory framework covering energy self-consumption has been included in REPowerEU revisions made by the energy ministry and will be activated by the issuance of a related ministerial decision expected within the first quarter of 2024.

The energy ministry will seek to have the ministerial decision issued before March, energypress sources informed.

The series of energy self-consumption revisions include a 100-KW net metering limit, from 3 MW, for large-scale enterprises.

In the lead-up, distribution network operator DEDDIE/HEDNO stopped accepting grid connection applications for net-metering PVs with capacities of over 100 KW.

As a result, companies needing to install higher-capacity RES systems must wait for the launch of net-billing as a solution. It promises real-time self-generation along with the sale of surplus energy.

The new self-production framework will also enable companies not possessing free space for PV installations to utilize solar energy through virtual net-billing solutions, or offsite PVs situated in other regions.

 

HAEE’s roundup of COP28 climate conference in Dubai

 

HAEE proudly and actively participated in #COP28 by powering up the future at Greece’s first-ever Pavilion, organizing the Side Event “Outlook of the Greek Energy Sector towards 2030”. We would like to thank our esteemed panel speakers, visionary leaders and guests who graced us with their presence or watched online and shared their insights on Greece’s accelerated transition away from fossil fuels, analyzed the latest reoriented policies, practices and investment priorities to deliver outcomes, protecting people, livelihoods, and ecosystems.

Let us share a roundup of what we witnessed on the ground at COP28:

On 13/12/2023, at the United Nations Climate Change Conference COP28 in Dubai, after intense overnight negotiations on whether the outcome would include a call to “phase down” or “phase out” fossil fuels, almost 200 nations reached an Agreement, to transition away from fossil fuels, while the negotiators set their commitments to triple renewables capacity and double energy efficiency by 2030, so as to achieve net zero by 2050.

COP28 adopted a decision on the outcome of the first global stocktake, which is a two-year process to assess progress on mitigation, adaptation and climate finance, and design the way forward. The parties recognised that, by 2030, global greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions have to be reduced by 43% below 1990 levels to restrict global warming to 1.5 °C, and committed to accelerating action in the current decade.

The Draft decision of COP28 – CMA.5 “Outcome of the first global stocktake” is now available here

An Agreement on the operationalisation of the Loss and Damage Fund was also decided. The fund will initially be hosted by the World Bank and It has received over US$700 million in pledges, with Germany and the United Arab Emirates offering US$100 million each .

The involved parties further adopted a framework adaptation, accompanied with 2030 targets for all parties to: conduct impact, vulnerability and risk assessments; adopt and implement adaptation plans and policy instruments; and set up monitoring, evaluation and learning systems for their national adaptation efforts.

After two weeks of intense discussions, the Deal that was reached in Dubai sends a strong statement to investors and decision-makers alike about the global community’s intention to move away from fossil fuels, something scientists say is the best chance to prevent a global warming disaster.

Let’s keep pushing boundaries and working towards a sustainable and brighter future!

Key uptakes of HAEE’s Side Event, at COP28

Let’s now deep dive into a micro-level and the insightful discussion we enjoyed on the 5th of December under the topic “Outlook of the Greek Energy Sector towards 2030” at HAEE’s Side Event that took place in the Greek Pavilion. The dynamic dialogue between esteemed speakers and visionary leaders was focused on the global, European, and Greek energy landscapes, the energy industry innovation, the impacts of Energy Transition and the ways of communicating the energy transition in a new climate narrative.

As Ms. Ditte Juul Jørgensen, Director General for Energy, European Commission, mentioned, the international community has prioritized the exponential deployment of renewables and energy efficiency improvements by 2030 to meet the collective goal of the Paris Agreement to keep warming well below 2°C and phase down or even phase out fossil fuels by mid-century. To that end, and after the initiation of the EU, 123 countries have signed the Global Renewables and Energy Efficiency Pledge, underlying the close link between the climate and energy objectives. As we step into the future, Greece has already re-introduced its goals and position to achieve or event to overcome EU’s climate obligations and emission target reductions, aiming to decarbonize its economy and transform itself into an energy hub in Southeastern Europe and the Western Balkans.

In the wake of the Russo-Ukrainian war and as the EU is decoupling from Russia’s energy supply, Greece is playing a critical role in securing Europe’s energy resilience through the Southern Gas Corridor, the TAP pipeline and other infrastructure projects such as the expansion of the Revithousa Terminal, the completion of the IGB pipeline and the commissioning of Alexandroupolis FSRU.

On top of that, as H.E. Geoffrey Pyatt, Assistant Secretary, Bureau of Energy Resources, U.S. Department of State, highlighted the overhaul of Alexandroupolis FSRU into a Western Balkans’, regional, emblematic Project. Greece’s connectivity moves in two strategic directions; one is to the Western Balkans, by helping the EU-aspiring countries to reduce their dependence on Russian energy and to the Mediterranean through the US, Greece, Cyprus, Israel and Egypt cooperation, to build a regional connection on gas, electricity through the interconnectors or even green hydrogen, aiming to build a future energy system which is not vulnerable to one supplier, which is economically competitive but also meet the climate targets.

Ms. Alexandra Sdoukou, Deputy Minister of Environment and Energy, Hellenic Republic confirmed that over the last years, Greece has transitioned into an exporting country of gas—mainly from the US— new interconnections are in progress, and RES have the potential to dominate the future energy mix, increasing the attractiveness of the Greek energy sector to potential investors, shaping sustainable business strategies and fostering a resilient future for the country.

Mr. Bertrand Piccard, Initiator and Chairman, Solarimpulse Foundation pointed out that the momentum to change the narrative of the economies’ and energy system’s decarbonization is now. There is a climate emergency, but also an economic emergency to switch to renewable energy and implement the necessary policy measures to save natural resources. The goal of authorities, academics, policy-makers and the relevant stakeholders has not to be the decarbonization with the sacrifice of the future generation, but to modernize the world, by making it efficient and profitable for the current generation. In that case, decarbonization will be the result of modernization.

Mr. Roman Kramarchuk, Head of Future Energy Analytics, S&P Global – Commodity Insights, commented that S&P energy markets’ “Green Rule Scenario” involves cooperation, cross-country support, and sharing of technologies as prerequisites, to achieve three times renewable. Market mechanisms such as PPA or corporate voluntary carbon markets are driving the change since corporate buyers are now willing to be able to demonstrate that they can operate sustainably and become policy-makers of their own right, supported by governments. This is a paradigm of multiple actors initiating for a common goal, the goal of achieving net-zero.

The political will exists, the technology exists, and the market mechanisms are ready to be implemented. Our focus should be on informing, motivating, engaging people and communities toward the energy transition.

HAEE is looking forward to next year’s event, COP29 which will take place in Baku, Azerbaijan, in November 2024 with the hope of a much more optimistic climate outlook!

Presenting our Chart of the Month Vol. 20, in the Side Event organized by the HAEE team and the Hellenic Ministry of Environment and Energy at the Greek Pavillion in COP28, is the epitome of ending the year on a high note! This special edition gives a more detailed outlook of the Greek energy market towards 2030 and 2050 through various topics encircling energy.

Based on the revised Greek NECP, key milestones and targets for the energy transition of the Greek energy market are presented across specific subtopics such as the future RES and energy storage developments, the Natural Gas landscape in Greece, the future outlook of the interconnections, as well as opportunities in innovative technologies like CCUS and Hydrogen production.

Special focus is placed on important topics that form the pillars of Greece’s strategy for the energy transition. One such topic is the development of offshore wind parks in the Aegean and Ionian Seas. The first such pilot project was recently announced in Alexandroupolis with capacity of 600 MW. Additionally, in Alexandroupolis, another interesting project, the FSRU terminal, is expected to become operational in 2024.

Finally, we explore the investment landscape of Greece which is thriving with a recently upgraded investment grade and forecasts of surpassing EU growth rates. Significant funding inflows via RRF and REPowerEU promise a bright future for the sector. Favorable conditions for both traditional and emerging renewable energy technologies, alongside pivotal infrastructure developments, position Greece as a key player in Europe‘s energy independence, with the overall ambition of transforming Greece into an energy hub for Europe.

Sub-station upgrades to maximize RES grid connections

Distribution network operator DEDDIE/HEDNO is closely examining the country’s power grid to determine which sub-stations it will choose to upgrade, the objective being to offer grid links to a greater number of RES projects.

The operator also intends to upgrade sub-stations in areas where investment interest for RES installations is high.

Grid capacity limits are already exhausted in areas where RES development has been extensive, especially when concerning RES technologies other than photovoltaics.

As part of the upgrade, the operator intends to modernize all necessary equipment at each substation, the cost of which it considers manageable.

Also, the operator will carry out studies to determine necessary network interventions close to each substation, especially replacement of conductors with small cross sections.

Stagnant RES projects to be terminated as ‘non-existent’

The energy ministry plans to classify RES projects that have secured connection terms but remained stagnant as non-existent in order to free grid capacity for new projects with development prospects.

According to data included in power grid operator IPTO’s ten-year development plan, RES projects with a capacity of approximately 14.9 GW are currently registered for development.

The eventual cancellation of stagnant RES projects could make available an estimated 2.5 GW in freed grid capacity for new projects. The exact figure on freed up grid capacity will be determined following IPTO’s inspection of the 14.9 GW portfolio.

This solution, clearing the grid of dormant RES projects, is intended to represent part of a wider effort by the energy ministry to utilize the grid and maximize RES growth in Greece.

Other initiatives are expected to include RES output grid-injection restrictions and mandatory installation of batteries to RES units in exchange for fixed tariffs.

RES cuts more cost-efficient than battery installations

RES cuts, to prevent grid overloads, appear to be the most competitive option available to small and medium-sized photovoltaics given the current cost of installing batteries behind the meter.

In the majority of cases, battery systems capable of providing stored energy to the grid over two-hour periods end up doubling the CAPEX cost of RES projects.

This essentially means that, at an operational level, without any state support for battery costs, tariffs would need to be doubled, especially in the cases of non-vertically integrated players, as was recently pointed out by Stelios Loumakis, president of SPEF, the Hellenic Association of Photovoltaic Energy Producers, during a presentation.

On the other hand, cutting RES grid input by 50 percent would result in annual PV park production losses of 20 percent, which could be compensated through a 25 percent tariff increase, a SPEF study showed, making this a more cost-efficient solution, the association’s president noted.

RES cuts, the SPF chief stressed, do not constitute a long-term viable solution as they restrict renewable energy supply, a pivotal factor if green energy is to further penetrate the system.

 

 

Brussels looks to block uncertain RES projects from outset

The European Commission has taken a further step aiming to free electricity grid capacities from uncertain projects by calling on energy regulators throughout the EU to establish disincentives and filters blocking indefinite investments from the beginning of application processes.

Brussels has decided to take action as a considerable number of RES investment plans in the EU have remained stagnant, including in Greece, needlessly occupying precious grid capacities.

The European Commission has issued instructions calling for national energy regulatory authorities to establish rules discouraging RES projects from the outset if investors behind the projects do not have serious intentions.

New stricter rules should be introduced throughout the EU to stop investors from submitting applications if they are not certain about follow-up action, Brussels has urged.

 

Fixed RES tariffs for bigger grid input limitations, batteries

The energy ministry plans to offer fixed tariffs, at RES auctions as of 2024, as an incentive to investors behind RES projects accepting increased grid injection limitations or an obligation to incorporate batteries, measures that would save grid capacity.

Deputy energy minister Alexandra Sdoukou announced this plan at a three-day energy conference, “Energy Security and Green Growth”, organized by the energy ministry.

A grid injection limitation of 50 percent of RES output is expected to be imposed on RES projects as a prerequisite for fixed tariffs. It remains unclear if the auctions offering these fixed tariffs will be technology-specific or mixed. According to energypress sources, the new auctions could only concern photovoltaics. Also the ministry is believed to be considering to offer a total capacity of 2 GW for fixed tariffs, though this, too, remains unfinalized.

Existing legislation covering RES auctions will need to be amended to facilitate the ministry’s fixed-tariffs plan.

 

 

 

Green-energy Guarantees of Origin auction in January

RES market operator DAPEEP plans to stage an inaugural auction offering Renewable Energy Guarantees of Origin early in the new year, within the first two weeks of January, according to energypress sources.

The forthcoming auction will come following months of preparations by DAPEEP. The effort will be completed with a link of the Greek register of Guarantees of Origin with the corresponding European registers.

The Greek system’s link with the corresponding European system will establish a connection with all markets on the continent.

Two pending issues remain ahead of the inaugural auction. RAAEY, the Regulatory Authority for Waste, Energy and Water, needs to approve relevant regulations and the platform, almost ready, must be completed. Neither issue is expected to delay the operator’s plans.

Proceeds generated at Renewable Energy Guarantees of Origin auctions will be injected into the country’s RES special account as an additional source of revenue.

A relevant legislative revision was made in the summer of 2022 to facilitate the introduction of Renewable Energy Guarantees of Origin, designed to provide transparency to consumers on the proportion of electricity that suppliers source from renewable generation, required of all EU member states.

COP28 Has To Be The Last COP

I have the feeling that 2023 will go down in history as the game changing year for the climate crisis.

But I am afraid it is the climate crisis itself which is changing the game and not us.

Just a couple of weeks before COP28 and everyone and everything is geared for the big event. They will all be there. Like before.

And, of course, everyone who is someone is acknowledging the importance of taking serious decisions to tackle the climate crisis.

The government, industry and business stakeholders are cautiously optimistic and the civil society stakeholders are cautiously pessimistic.

As always, the end result will be a compromise where system stakeholders will promise less that they could do and far less than they should do and in actual fact deliver even less, while civil societies will celebrate minor victories and criticize COP for not rising to the critical occasion, molded by stark climate reality.

Finally, they will renew their rendezvous for next year, like they have been doing for 28 years.

COP’s have become annual gatherings, like trade fairs.

Like a jamboree.

But it cannot be so. It must not be so.

We are dealing with a clear, direct threat to human existence.

We cannot have market rules and politicians’ aspirations, guided by extremely short time horizons, derail and mislead COP judgment and decisions.

Science is above all and science has been clear all along for 28 consecutive COP sessions.

Yet, the leaders of humanity have been anything but homo sapiens.

As is always customary before a COP, reports by UN institutions and globally renowned organisations summarizing the state of play, are published.

Reading them is not pleasant.

For example, a UN report published on November 14th 2023 reads:

New Analysis of National Climate Plans: Insufficient Progress Made, COP28 Must Set Stage for Immediate Action

The opening paragraph reads: “A new report from UN Climate Change finds national climate action plans remain insufficient to limit global temperature rise to 1.5 degrees Celsius and meet the goals of the Paris Agreement. Even with increased efforts by some countries, the report shows much more action is needed now to bend the world’s emissions trajectory further downward and avoid the worst impacts of climate change.”

Ask yourselves how many times you have read similar paragraphs?

Why is there nothing done?

Another news item published on November 17th, 2023 in Inside Climate News, is even clearer

“New Research Makes it Harder to Kick The Climate Can Down the Road from COP28”, 

stating in no uncertain terms that: “Without immediate emissions cuts, global temperatures will breach the Paris Agreement’s goals sooner than expected, scientists say. ‘Despite decades of warnings, we are still heading in the wrong direction’

It doesn’t just say that we are not doing enough.

It says we are heading in the wrong direction.

And it is not the only report to do so.

The Systems Change Labwhich is convened by World Resources Institute and Bezos Earth Fund, and supports the UN Climate Change High-Level Champions, published a few days ago the State of Climate Action 2023

From the various findings of the report, one stands out, in my opinion.

eport, one stands out, in my opinion.

It is a report on a set of 42 indicators, worked out by scientists, which characterize the state of the current climate action in comparison to what is needed to maintain the possibility of keeping global temperature rise below 1.5 degrees C.

Image

Read and try to keep your cool:

  • 1 (one) out of 42 is on track
  • 6 are off track
  • 24 are well off track
  • 6 are in the opposite direction and
  • 5 insufficient data, but they don’t appear promising

At this point feel free to panic, but if you are still with me, let me share some more scary stories. For the sake of brevity, I will share the news headlines and you can browse yourself.

And let’s start with the COP presidency not practicing what it preaches, as COP28 presidency of course, because as oil producers they do just fine.

We all know that the temperature rise is breaking new records, but it is wise to keep it in mind……

……because the culprit, CO2 emissions, are not decreasing. On the contrary:

It is no wonder then that the carbon budget to keep temperature rise below 1.5oC will be exceeded, erasing all hopes of meeting this emblematic lifesaving target 

Simply because fossil fuel companies trust their revenue lines and the stock exchange way more than science and carry on with business as usual.

So much so that the cost of the climate crisis, the loss and damage incurred by the hour, the deaths, the destruction, the despair, the displacement, carry no weight in their decisions.

This is the reality.

We are heading for an unprecedented disaster and time is not running out, but it has already run out. All that is left for us to do is to cut our losses.

COP28 is not a jamboree. It is not a cocktail party.

COP28 has to deliver the one and only solution we all know. Even those who oppose it.

To immediately start phasing out Fossil Fuels the fastest technically possible way.

COP28 cannot kick the climate can down the COP road.

Hence, COP28 has to be kept going until white smoke (powerful symbolism) rises.

It is the only solution that will save (literary) the day.

And this means that COP28 has to be the last COP

Either because it has delivered what it set out to deliver or because it has pitifully failed its mandate and we have to seek another way to reach the scientifically mandated solution.

Either way there cannot be a COP29.

Dr. Ioannis Tsipouridis

Renewable Energy Consultant Engineer

Technical Advisor of Research & Internationialisation & Visiting Professor @Meru University of Science and Technology (MUST)

Director of RECCReC (Renewable Energy & Climate Change Research Center at TUM) & Visiting Professor at Technical University of Mombasa (TUM)

Subsea survey for Greek-Italian cable capacity boost early 2024

A project aiming to triple the capacity of the Greek-Italian electrical grid interconnection is set for a challenging stage that entails thorough mapping of the seabed along the existing line’s 220-km route.

Survey work for this project is planned to begin in early 2024 following an agreement reached earlier this week at a wide-ranging Athens meeting between Giuseppina Di Foggia, CEO at Italian grid operator TERNA, and Manos Maousakis, the chief executive at Greek power grid operator IPTO.

The TERNA chief was joined by a team that included the company’s CFO as well as the head of major projects and international development.

Greece is under growing pressure to establish new export outlets for the country’s excess renewable energy. The country’s electricity exporting activity is becoming more frequent during midday hours. Also, Italy, it should be pointed out, is Europe’s biggest electricity importer.

According to sources, the Greek and Italian power grid operators are exploring all options, based on the respective experience of each company, to boost the capacity of the Greek-Italian subsea cable link from 500 MW to 1,500 MW as swiftly and efficiently as possible.

At this week’s meeting, held Tuesday, IPTO and TERNA also agreed on the need for new corridors transporting RES production from southern to central Europe.

TERNA, Europe’s biggest operator, is a highly influential market player operating 26 international interconnections and present on three continents.

 

Apollo RES support program an opportunity for 1.1 GW in PVs

Solar energy system investors are expressing strong interest to participate in Apollo, a 20-year RES support program presented early this month by the energy ministry and envisaged to offer RES output to low-income households, local government organizations, as well as public drainage and municipal water supply and sewerage companies.

This program has generated investor interest as it is expected to provide a development outlet for RES projects with a total capacity of 1.1 GW. It will also enhance grid-capacity preservation.

At present, roughly 8 GW in wind and solar energy projects with finalized connection offers have yet to secure tariffs for sale of output to the energy market. This shortcoming is creating financing obstacles for investors as banks hesitate to extend loans to customers without steady revenues. If they do decide to offer loans under such high-risk circumstances, interest rates are set extremely high.

Through the Apollo program, investors would succeed in derisking, or hedging risk, as the program is practically like signing a 20-year bilateral contract with the state as an off-taker.

The program also promises to boost new RES capacity, which, without Apollo, would be limited to the capacity offered by the approved RES licensing procedure, foreseeing 2 GW in new projects by 2025.

However, questions remain as to whether measures will be introduced to offset the program’s cost for the RES special account.

 

Project group to prepare framework for RES output cuts

A project management group recently founded by the energy ministry will, as its first task, prepare a recommendation for the ministry concerning the establishment of framework regulating green-energy output cuts over a long-term period, meeting the grid’s needs and further RES penetration for at least ten to fifteen years.

The group, led by head coordinator Stavros Papathanasiou, professor at the National Technical University of Athens, includes officials from the energy ministry, energy exchange, power grid operator IPTO, distribution network operator DEDDIE/HEDNO, and RES market operator DAPEEP.

The proposed permanent framework is expected to distribute RES output cuts across various project categories.

The group will also consider whether RES projects not injecting output into the system should be compensated, under specific terms and conditions.